Comparisons

The Battle of Oversized and Overpriced SUVs: 2015 Navigator vs. 2015 Escalade

Comparisons
@meisejohn

John is a full-time automotive blogger who digs cars, but also spends a disturbing amount of time watching and reading about movies. His first car was a maroon 1993 Buick Skylark which, after a solid seven-year run, was laid to rest in August of 2013.

2015 Lincoln Navigator vs 2015 Cadillac Escalade

One of the most mediocre presentations at the Chicago Auto Show was for the unveiling of the “new” 2015 Lincoln Navigator. Lincoln had been building up the hype for their SUV, but only about thirty people were there to watch the curtain get pulled off. That’s because Lincoln once again decided to “refresh” rather than redesign the Navigator.

The SUV has been following roughly the same design since 2007, and if Lincoln plans to have a rapper namedrop the Navigator ever again, they really have to stop dicking around.

Just listen to rap songs from the past couple of years. When is the last time you heard anyone relevant even mention a Navigator? It’s probably been since 2003 when R. Kelly spoke of poppin’ Cristal in a stretch Navigator in the always classy “Ignition (Remix).” The new 2015 Navigator is supposed to be Lincoln’s answer to the Cadillac Escalade, but a closer look at both of the vehicles shows that the Navigator is more of a backup singer than a star.

2015 Navigator vs 2015 Escalade

 
2015 Lincoln Navigator
2015 Cadillac Escalade
MSRPN/A$71,695
Engine3.5-liter V66.2-liter V8
Horsepower370420
Maximum Cargo Capacity103.3 cu.ft.94.2 cu.ft.
Wheels20's22's SON!!!!
2015-lincoln-navigator-chicago-auto-show

Barely anyone showed up for the reveal of the 2015 Lincoln Navigator.

For the “refresh” the exterior of the Navigator has received a number of upgrades that include a larger split-wing grille (which I still hate passionately), upgrades to just about every light on the damn thing and a lower air intake. It comes standard with 20’s. 20’s? You shittin’ me?! 20’s?! It’s no wonder why no one has been rapping about this thing.

The 2015 Escalade comes standard with 22’s—now we’re talking. The SUV also just received a complete redesign for the 2014 model year, so it’s still fresher than a motherfucker. The front end is much more attractive than the Navigator, and even though it’s using last year’s lights, they still look a hell of a lot more badass than the new lights that have been slapped on the 2015 Navigator.

Both the Navigator and the Escalade come with drive modes, but only one of the models actually has modes that make sense. The Escalade comes with the choice of Tour or Sport mode—sounds logical. The Navigator on the other hand, offers a Normal, Sport and Comfort mode. Comfort mode? Wouldn’t that be Normal mode? Or is Normal mode just extremely uncomfortable? It’s one of the many things about the Navigator that just don’t make sense to me.

Lincoln did do one thing right for the 2015 model. They finally got rid of the gas-chugging 5.4-liter V8 that has been plaguing the nose of the SUV for the last couple of years. It has been replaced with a more efficient 3.5-liter turbocharged V6 that gets 50 horsepower less than the Escalade’s 6.2-liter V8, but as it cuts out two cylinders completely, it will likely pull in higher fuel economy ratings.

2015-cadillac-escalade-chicago-auto-show

Fresher than a motherfucker.

The Escalade’s engine is equipped with variable valve timing and active fuel management that allows it to run on a limited number of cylinders. Past Escalades have utilized the same technology so we would expect the 2015 model to return figures in the ballpark of 14 mpg in the city and 18 mpg on the highway. As the Navigator is taking on a brand new engine, we’re not quite sure what to expect, but as the V8 was able to achieve 20 mpg on the highway, we would have to assume that the V6 will top that—then again, who really knows with Lincoln.

Despite the addition of the new, seemingly more efficient engine, I still have to give this one to the Escalade. Not only does it still get name-dropped by relevant rappers, but Cadillac has proved that they actually give a shit. The fact that Lincoln has went seven years without a redesign is just mind blowing. It would make more sense if the Navigator has found continued success over the past seven years, but it hasn’t. Lincoln needs to get their shit straight if they ever want to be a serious competitor with the Escalade.

Plus, 20’s?! You shittin’ me?!

Winner of the CarDebate: 2015 Cadillac Escalade

The Navigator is a one-hit wonder that has been remixed over and over for the past seven years, and unless Lincoln produces a brand new track, they’re never going to find themselves on the list of top hits ever again.

View Comments (6)

6 Comments

  1. LincolnMKZ

    Mar 13, 2014 at 5:19 pm

    The new 2015 Navigator comes optional with 22 inch rims not just 20’s!

  2. MEEEEEEEEEEEEE

    Jun 17, 2014 at 11:17 pm

    You are a hater!!!!
    Just because of your dried-ass facts we are supposed to believe you?
    The Lincoln Navigator is still my favourite SUV

  3. Taylor

    Jun 29, 2014 at 8:59 pm

    First, let me start by saying that you sound like a really classy and educated individual based on your language. “Motherfucker” and “Shit” are excellent words to use while doing a professional car review.
    I don’t understand how ANY one could take you seriously. Its the people like you who like Cadillac’s. Broke, uneducated, and couldn’t afford a Lincoln to begin with. Oh, and by the way how are those 22 Million GM recalls going? *Cough* And the 2 Government bailouts for GM? GM products suck, just like the quality of this new Cadillac Escalade. Its got taillights that look like fluorescent ceiling lamps and a rear end that looks like GM cut the back of it off to be used on another shitty Cadillac.

  4. On

    Sep 18, 2014 at 2:06 am

    Lmfaoooo navi s better

  5. Machelle

    Oct 24, 2014 at 12:48 am

    What a foul mouth, disgusting display of “journalism”. My goodness, are you on drugs?

  6. U&R

    Apr 23, 2015 at 11:43 pm

    Well I saw the new Lincoln Nav. and was disappointed they down graded the grill. Overall the inside chrome is a touch of class I hate they changed all chrome Lincoln symbols from the interior side doors to just a plain chrome. The seating did not have the logo either. Heartbroken and confused about which one to purchase. Currently it looks like a FORD.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


+ 5 = ten

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

More in Comparisons

2016 mustang vs 2016 camaro

2016 Ford vs Chevy Battle Could Be The Best Yet

Wes LungwitzNov 26, 2014
Nissan GT-R Kim Kardashian

Kim Kardashian Breaks Internet, So Nissan Breaks Her

Tyler SjostromNov 13, 2014
corvette vs viper

Did The 2015 Corvette Defeat The Viper In The Battle For Supercar Supremacy?

Wes LungwitzSep 18, 2014
jeep renegade luaz 1302

The Ukranian LuAZ Takes On The New Jeep Renegade

Wes LungwitzMar 8, 2014
white-tigerzord-vs-honda-fcev-concept

Honda Concept Or Power Ranger Robot Warrior?

Brian VogelFeb 20, 2014
2015-chrysler-200-vs-2014-honda-accord

Redesign Gives Chrysler 200 A Fighting Chance Against Honda Accord

John MeiseFeb 18, 2014
2015-ford-mustang-vs-2014-chevy-camaro

The Battle Of The Ponies: 2015 Mustang vs. 2014 Camaro

John MeiseFeb 17, 2014
2014-Ram-1500-EcoDiesel-vs-2015-Nissan-Titan-Diesel

Nissan Titan Diesel Gets Ram 1500 EcoDiesel’s Sloppy Seconds

John MeiseFeb 14, 2014
chevy-reaper-vs-ford-raptor

Ford Raptor Has No Reason To Fear The Reaper

Lance KozicFeb 8, 2014